|
|
From: Scott Marshall
The Fight Against Racism Today
(Reprinted from the July issue of Political Affairs, monthly
journal of the Communist Party, USA. For subscription information
see below - all rights reserved.)
(Editor's Note: This discussion article was prepared by the
National Board of the Communist Party. Readers are encouraged to
respond to the concepts and problems raised in it. Responses can
be handwritten, typed or can be put on a computer disk. Comments
can be from 3000 to 6000 words. If you don't like to write put
your thoughts on a tape and send it in. Let us know what you
think.)
This educational discussion aims to raise the level of
understanding and stimulate militant action of our Party in the
fight against racism.
The fight against racism is an immediate and urgent challenge to
our Party. To meet this challenge, we are undertaking a new level
of collective ideological struggle within the Party to deepen our
working-class approach to this struggle.
We need an updated assessment of where the class and people's
movements are in the fight against racism, of the specific
expressions of the increased level of racism and its impact on
the class struggle. There are many new developments, the
significance of which has not yet been fully grasped. A full
collective discussion will make clearer our picture of how mass
thought patterns and class consciousness are being influenced by
the increased use of racism by the ruling class, a full
discussion of our Party's collective experience in the fight
against racism will improve our practical work and initiative.
The discussion should strengthen understanding of what is needed
to build the strongest, broadest unity to help the movements go
on the offensive.
The document discusses the following areas:
- what are the main features of the ruling class' increased
promotion of racism;
- how does the increase in racism relate to the systemic crisis
of capitalism;
- what are the key issues in the fight against racism today;
- what are the basics of our Marxist-Leninist analysis and
approach;
- what is the Party's role on this critical fight.
Effect of Systemic Crisis - The deepening of capitalism's
systemic crisis combined with the legacy of 12 years of
Reagan-Bush's unprecedentedly racist offensive, which has been
extended and deepened by the Clinton administration, have brought
about a dramatic increase in the effects of racism. The fact that
there are still some illusions about the nature of this
administration has made it more difficult to fight in some ways.
The increase in racism must be placed in the context of the
crisis of capitalism - because it is the capitalist class which
benefits from racism, using it to divide and to confuse the
people about the reasons for the economic and social crisis of
the system. Because the system is in crisis, there is an increase
in the intensity and complexity of the ongoing ideological war on
class unity and the principles and practice of equality.
The racist use of the crime issue, rising racist and police
violence, deepening segregation, criminalization, attacks on
immigrants, increasing poverty, homelessness and unemployment, an
increase in stereotypes in the mass media, and environmental
racism all indicate the depth of the crisis.
These tendencies must be seen within the context of the
intensification of the class struggle. Corporate "downsizing" and
mass layoffs in industry have led to an overall decline in the
living standards of the working class, especially its racially
and nationally oppressed components, and have exacerbated the
growth of racism. These things are directly connected.
Capitalism's systemic crisis adds a whole new dimension to these
problems. "Downsizing" and mass layoffs have wiped out many of
the past gains against discrimination in the workplace. As the
economic crisis deepens, new forms of economic racism are making
themselves felt.
Massive unemployment, poverty and homelessness are its most
direct and vivid result. Unemployment rates among African
American, Latino, and Asian workers are twice those of whites,
long-term unemployment is also particularly severe. A large
percent of the homeless are Black and Latino. Economic racism's
hideousness is particularly seen in its impact on Black and
Latino children, close to half of whom live in poverty.
A key feature of the intensification of racism in this period is
the level and quality of segregation. Segregation has accelerated
rather than declined and has become sharper, characterized by
deep poverty and extremely poor conditions of life. This is cause
for closer examination of the significance of segregation today,
not only as a by-product of economic factors but as a deliberate
corporate and governmental policy, with far-reaching
implications.
From the reservation system - formal, legalized segregation - to
the Black and Latino inner city ghettos, segregation is a result
of monopoly capitalism's drive for super- profits.
It is the result of corporate and governmental policies including
red-lining and the Reagan and Bush administrations' cuts in
housing and urban spending, which have resulted in the
devastation of inner city neighborhoods. The attack on federal
funding for building and maintaining public housing has brought
terrible results; added to this is the Clinton administration's
callously racist - and telling - proposal to use HUD monies to
build prisons.
Racial and class segregation has produced a segregated school
system, and contributed to the sharp downward slide in the
quality of education received by Black and Latino children all
over the country. The privatization of public education is
worsening this problem and creating new inequalities.
The crisis of segregation facing all racially and nationally
oppressed and especially African Americans is a direct result of
the structural crisis of the late 70s and 80s and the corporate
downsizing of the 90s. These ghettos and barrios must be
understood as an essential aspect of the special oppression of
these peoples - class, racial, and national - and a means of
controlling and cutting these communities off from the rest of
society, and of physically dividing the working class.
New studies point to what is termed "hypersegregation" of African
Americans in the nation's largest industrial cities - LA,
Houston, Newark, Chicago, Detroit, New York, Cleveland,
Philadelphia, cities in which the structural crisis and long-term
and generational unemployment have been sharpest. By
hypersegregation is meant the geographic, political, economic and
cultural isolation of these communities. This hypersegregation
reveals that racism directed at African Americans has a unique
quality and has reached a new and unprecedented stage.
Economic racism is also related to the crisis of the cities,
where most ghettos and barrios are located. As basic industries
move out, services are allowed to decline, streets fall apart,
bridges crumble. Here the drug crisis continues unabated, infant
mortality rates zoom to levels above those in the Third World,
and diseases like AIDS and tuberculosis rage almost out of
control. Here the communities are in a virtual state of siege as
racist police departments, under the pretext of fighting drugs,
terrorize and intimidate. Here Black and Brown youth are
routinely rounded up in sweeps, and have filled the nation's
jails and prisons to the point of overflow, with 35 percent of
African American youth either in jail or under the control of the
criminal justice system.
For Black and Brown people, racism means shorter, less healthy,
less-valued lives.
Assault on Civil Rights - Directly connected to this is the
ruling class' sharpened attack all down the line on civil rights.
Reagan-appointed judges dominate the courts; existing civil
rights laws are weak and are not enforced; affirmative action has
suffered from a prolonged ideological attack on the very idea of
it, and especially on the concepts of quotas and timetables,
based on the false notion that discrimination is a thing of the
past. The dropping of the nomination of Lani Guinier is
illustrative of the Clinton administration's betrayal of civil
rights.
Voting rights are under severe attack. The Supreme Court's
overturning of the North Carolina Congressional district created
to insure greater representation has elevated to the status of
law the concept that the "civil rights of whites" are violated by
the Voting Rights Act's remedies to make up for past
discrimination.
In fact affirmative action is under a two-edged assault. On the
one side, there is an almost complete undermining of its legal
and political foundations by the right-wing Supreme Court which
has rendered decisions claiming that certain forms of affirmative
action are unconstitutional. On the other is the elimination of
the intended effects of affirmative action in industry by the new
rounds of layoffs. As recent studies indicate, these layoffs are
having a profound impact on all racially and nationally oppressed
workers; on Latinos, Asians, Native American Indians and
especially African Americans.
The increase in racism must be seen in the context of the crisis
of capitalism and its drive to maintain the $225 billion of
super-profits based on the difference in wages paid to African
American, Latino, and Asian workers as compared to whites for the
same work.
The wholesale attempt to eliminate social programs like Social
Security, welfare, and unemployment benefits, and the creation of
a new "contingent" work force, many of whom are Black, Brown and
women have led to the re-emergence of concepts that the racially
and nationally oppressed are social pariahs beyond hope and that
"money should not be wasted on them." Coupled with this
ideological assault is Clinton's new crime bill which is a new
and dangerous legal instrument for the creation of capitalism
without entitlements.
This assault is aimed in particularly sharp ways at women of
color, who are blamed for the problems of the community in
general and of the youth in particular. The reality is the low
wages received by Black and Latina women workers, and the
extremely high rates of poverty - two-thirds of Puerto Rican
households headed by women are poor. The Clinton administration's
attack on welfare is aimed at racially and nationally oppressed
women and their families, and exposes the hypocrisy of talk of
"family values" by the administration.
Institutionalized Racism - Racism is ruling- class ideology and
is the concept and practice of white supremacy. It is the
practice of discrimination and oppression based on skin color,
physical characteristics, continent of origin and culture. It has
its origins as a justification for slavery and the conquest of
the Americas. From the beginning, slavery in the United States
was tied to the development and growth of capitalism. Founded on
the sale and ownership of human beings on the basis of their
physical characteristics and color, its purpose was the
exploitation of unpaid labor for super profits. As chattels,
Africans were hunted like animals, transported to the "New
World," and then sold on the auction block like beasts of burden.
In like manner Native American Indians were exterminated on a
massive scale.
Moral and intellectual rationales were invented to justify this
kidnapping, sale, enslavement and genocide against human beings.
As an ideology, racism provided the moral and intellectual
underpinnings of slavery, the westward expansion of colonialism
and the seizure of half of Mexico. Thus the purpose of this
doctrine was, and still is, to put forward ideas and theories
founded on the myth that people of color are inherently inferior.
Almost 130 years after the Emancipation Proclamation, the legacy
of slavery remains. It is embedded in and influences every aspect
of social, economic and political life. This is what is meant by
institutionalized racism.
Institutionalized racism is the combined economic, political,
social, cultural, legal, ideological and other structures that
exist to maintain the system of inequality.
As a set of institutions, racism is infused in the very
foundations of our society and is inseparable from the economic
foundations of U.S. capitalist society. The racist wage gap is a
most fundamental feature: both in terms of the superprofits
produced by the superexploitation of racially oppressed workers,
and the additional extra profits created by the fact that racism
divides and weakens the working class and drags down wages for
all workers.
A Special System of Oppression - Racism must be understood as a
special system of oppression dependent on the capitical life and
affects the thought patterns of millions. Because of this, the
solution to racist oppression rests on dismantling its structures
in society and in the economy.
Institutionalized racism has economic, social, political,
ideological and cultural forms, and denies equality, justice and
dignity to all people of color. Because its roots are in
capitalism's drive to maxnd in the history of U.S. capitalism's
development, racism has an especially sharp impact on racially
and nationally oppressed ways: on African American workers, who
in the last recession experienced the greatest job loss on a
national average and who t experience high unemployment and who
are harassed and persecuted related to their status; on Puerto
Rican workers, whose famat the highest rate; on Native American
Indian workers in the cities and especially on the reservations,
among whom unemployment, a much lower-than-average life
expectancy and poor health care are the norm; and on Asian
workers, who are forced to work ight for unity in a given
situation.
For example, the closing of factories has had an especially
severe impact on African American workers, a large percentage of
whom are concentrated in industry. In the latest recession Black
workers were the only segment of the work-force to experience a
net job loss. Complicating the racist pattern in layoffs are new
company-imposed literacregulations, which have resulted in
further layoffs of Black workers who avoided layoffs by having
sufficient seniority. Unablorkers have been forced out of their
jobs in large numbers, even in the steel industry, where the
consent decrees of the 1970so have less plant-wide seniority.
An important feature of racism's new forms is the new vigor of
the anti-immigrant campaign, d Asian workers. This campaign
places the blame for unemployment, government budget deficits,
etc, on immigration. It is an old idea, but was given new
attention in the battle around NAFTA, and was aimed particularly
at Mexican workers and Mexican AmerAnti-Arab racism is flagrantly
promoted in the media and in popular culture. Hysteria and
hostility towards Arab peoples have been deliberately and
systematically whipped up, particularly around the time of the
Gulf War, and since. It has been used especially to create
diversions, though temporary, from attention to the real problems
of the U.S. working class. The promotion of for the economic
crisis. The decision of the Clinton administration to reverse its
policy on Haitian refugees is an essential part of the campaign
against immigrants in general.
A difficult and dangerous problem which has also sharpened in
this period is the pitting of oppressed nationalities against one
another. The ruling class and its media paint a picture of
widespread and deepening antagonisms between peoples, and the
notion that equality and unity are not possible. Building unity
of all racially and nationally oppressed is a key part of the
fight for the interests of the whole class.
Similarity of Oppression - The differing forms of racial
oppression against people of color has in no way mitigated the
similarity of their oppression. Racism gives a common character
to their status within the U.S. Hence, their emancipation,
irrespective of nationality, is dependent upon a common and
united struggle of all working people against racism.
In this regard the struggle against economic racism has a
particular importance. The fight against it must be the
foundation of any campaign for real equality. In situations in
which close to half the African American and Latino populations
live at or near the poverty line, the fight for equality for
these victims of the crisis must be the point of departure for
full equality for racially and nationally peoples as a whole.
In his report to the Communist Party's Mid-term Conference,
Comrade Hall said,
Poverty and racism have become a deadly twosome. Thus, there can
be no effective fight against racism without a struggle against
poverty. And there can be no effective fight against poverty
without taking on the struggle against racism and for equality.
Such a guiding principle is necessary in the struggle for
working-class unity.
This is the basis for the Conference call for an all-out campaign
for jobs and equality, launched and promoted by our Party. The
fight for a massive federal jobs program, with strong affirmative
action provisions, and for new, stronger Civil Rights laws, is
the basis for unity in this period. It will be the proving ground
for commitment to the fight for equality and against racism.
The racism that appeared during Clinton's election campaign has
now emerged full- blown after less than one year in office. Part
and parcel of Clinton's caving in to pressure from the right has
been capitulation to racism, from the abandonment of the Guinier
nomination to the "anti-crime" campaign, which is essentially a
call for "jails, not jobs." It is a call to establish a new legal
basis for monopoly capitalism in the 21st century, a capitalism
where workers have no benefits and Black and Brown workers no
rights. The Clinton administration has come out more and more
openly as the spokesperson for the policies of the transnational
corporations.
It is ominous that the president who was elected on the basis of
rejection of Reagan- Bush policies made the kind of arrogant and
overtly racist speech that Clinton did in Memphis in November at
a national meeting of Black ministers.
Perhaps the most unashamedly racist speech by a president, or any
public official, was Clinton's "off-the-cuff,
straight-from-the-heart" speech in which he lamented the "great
crisis of the spirit that is gripping America today." Using
codewords and themes such as "personal responsibility," "family
stability" and "family pathologies," he reverted to the old
themes of blaming the victims, revealing a president deeply
infected with racism. This address will go down in history as
infamous, reviving the oldest and worst racist stereotypes,
bigotry and ignorance.
Underlying this speech is the ruling class' attitude about the
special conditions racism has created. It was an attack on the
gains of the civil rights battles, cynically abusing the memory
and legacy of Martin Luther King. The speech was a most audacious
expression of the false notion that the problems of crime and
violence are due to a "lack of family values." This problem, the
president insisted, causes murder and mayhem to occur in the
country's ghettos and barrios with "reckless abandonment." In
other words, Black people are totally out of control and must be
restrained by any means necessary. This concept reflects the
ruling class' attempt to "criminalize" an entire people on the
basis of race, and has very dangerous implications, including
that it is a justification for police brutality and racist
vigilantism.
Not satisfied with his Memphis performance he shortly afterwards
traveled to Los Angeles, where he put forth the same ideas
directed at the Mexican American community, this time invoking
the image of Cesar Chavez. Clinton's racist anti-crime campaign
has been matched by California's right-wing Governor Wilson, who
has called for building more prisons as a priority.
Clinton's speeches are aimed to divert and confuse, to point the
finger away from monopoly capital, which is in fact responsible
for the deterioration of the neighborhoods and standard of living
of African American and other racially oppressed people, and
especially their working-class component. His message was quite
clear: don't look to the government to solve these problems,
don't look to the obvious reasons - joblessness and poverty,
racism and discrimination - for crime, drugs and violence.
Clinton's statement that, "unless we do something about crime I
we will not be able to repair this country" is a cover for
government inaction on the economic crisis, when in fact what is
required is a massive federal jobs program, legislation to
enforce and strengthen affirmative action, a new Civil Rights
Act, strengthening labor's rights, and laws which cut into
monopoly profits (increasing corporate taxes, shorter work week,
increase in the minimum wage, etc.).
Most importantly Clinton's overt racism in his Memphis speech
gives the green light to racist forces around the country - this
is racism led by the president. It must not be forgotten that
Perot's United We Stand America, Pat Buchanan and the even more
reactionary fundamentalist fanatic fringe like Robertson's
Christian Coalition are working feverishly to cash in as the
patience of disillusioned Clinton supporters gives way to anger.
By resorting to racism himself, the President is adding fuel to
these ultra- right fires.
Foreign Policy - The blatant racism of the president is also
revealed in his militarist foreign policy. Racism is being used -
along with its evil twin, anti-Communism - to justify aggressive
actions in pursuit of a world "safe" for corporate profiteering.
The administration has wrapped itself in a mantle of militarism
and racist arrogance, from Somalia to Haiti, to North Korea,
acting on the one superpower premise.
U.S. imperialism has justified its muscle flexing and aggressive
actions towards Somalia and Haiti using a thinly veiled racist
rationale - that the people of those countries have reached a
state of barbarism and anarchy and are incapable of governing
themselves. Implied and at times even stated is the idea that
these countries have problems because the people are less
"civilized." Covered up is the fact that the U.S. itself armed
and trained Duvalier's regime and had a hand in Somalia as well.
The concept of "nation-building" is also a thinly disguised
cover-up of imperialism's intent to control other countries. The
notion that the U.S. needs "win-win" capability - to be able to
fight and win two wars at once - is crude in its arrogance. Anti-
Communism and racism shaped the recent confrontation with North
Korea over the issue of nuclear weapons, in which the U.S. not
only claimed to have the right to decide which countries can
develop such weapons, but threatened to use them.
There are obvious similarities between these developments in the
foreign policy arena and the administration's domestic policy:
between the concept that the solution to the massive social and
economic problems at home is more police and more prisons, while
internationally, U.S. imperialism openly announces its intention
to use military force to impose "order" wherever necessary to
protect corporate interests.
the Labor Movement - The intensification of racism goes hand in
hand with the overall offensive of monopoly. The two are
interwoven and interact with one another in economic, political
and social life. From the standpoint of monopoly capital they are
but two sides of a single policy whose aim is not only to add
billions to the year-end profit statements of the capitalist
class, but also to slow down and reverse the new trends towards
multi-racial working-class and all-people's unity that are so
evident today. The growing strength and future potential of these
trends has not been missed in the corporate boardrooms nor by the
well-paid image makers of monopoly capital.
While the overall offensive of monopoly capital has driven down
the living standards of the working class with a disproportionate
and heavy burden falling upon the victims of racial and national
oppression, its other class aim of busting up multi-racial,
multi- national working class and people's unity, has proved more
elusive.
Indeed, the greatest progress in the fight against racism has
been among the working class. Black, Brown, and white
working-class unity has mushroomed. It is deeper and broader
today. It expresses itself through a variety of issues and forms
as well as in diverse arenas.
It most forcefully expresses itself around economic issues and in
the economic arena. And in the recent struggle against NAFTA
multi-racial, multi-national unity took a new leap and reached a
new level. The ideological fog of white and great power
chauvinism which has been lessening over the past decade was
blown away in no small measure. This occurred among substantial
sections of the labor movement.
Likewise, the coalition and alliance relationships between labor
and the racially and nationally oppressed also have emerged in a
new way. The labor-African American alliance, playing as it has a
pivotal role at many turning points in the nation's development,
has moved to a new stage as reflected by the August 28th
demonstration for Jobs, Peace, and Justice, the first major
challenge to the Clinton administration.
Similarly, the relations between labor and the Mexican American
people and other movements of the racially and nationally
oppressed have also moved to higher ground. In this, the role of
Mexican American workers has given a fresh and dynamic impulse to
both labor and the labor-community alliance.
The new level of Black, Brown, and white unity is the ground for
new initiatives, for a counteroffensive against monopoly, for a
winning struggle against the transnational corporations and the
Clinton administration.
Of course, this process of unification did not happened
overnight, but rather has been molded by subjective as well as
objective processes. Needless to say, it has not been without
snags and detours, even setbacks along way.
Nonetheless, the fact is that the struggle against NAFTA brings
the struggle for multi- racial working-class and people's unity
to a new stage. In doing so, it presents new opportunities in the
labor movement in terms of the struggle against racism and for
full equality.
The most important and enduring spinoff of the NAFTA fight was
the growth of class consciousness. A worker who is coming to
think in class terms more easily understands the interconnection
between the class struggle and the struggle against racism. A
worker who sees the profit drive of the transnational
corporations as the cause of the systemic economic crisis can be
more easily convinced of the need for special measures to address
the racist patterns of layoffs. A worker who is beginning to
understand the nature of class exploitation is more apt to see
the special system of exploitation and oppression directed
against Black and Brown workers as well as the common class
interests of all workers.
In short, the growth of class consciousness is the force field to
protect against influences of white chauvinism and racist
ideology. It is the ideological backdrop to raise still higher
the anti-racist sentiment and understanding among white workers.
And, most importantly, it is the springboard from which new, bold
initiatives against racism and for equality can be launched.
Struggle for Affirmative Action - In the center of labor's
struggles for jobs, health care, housing, and other urgent needs
should be found the issue of affirmative action. It is an
indispensible element in the fight for multi-racial and
all-people's unity. And without Black, Brown, and white unity
victory against monopoly capital is impossible.
But it won't be easy. The struggle for affirmative action, and
the ruling class assault on it, has been fierce precisely because
it lies at the intersection of the struggle against class and
racial oppression, against exploitation and super-exploitation.
Over the past two decades the labor movement has taken principled
positions on affirmative action. It has become a more effective
and active fighter against racism. But more needs to be done both
because of the systemic nature of the economic crisis and
because of the ruling class assault on affirmative action.
At the same time, the new anti-racist thought patterns among
workers make possible the upping of the ante in the fight against
racism and for Black, Brown, and white working-class unity. They
make possible a new boldness in terms of moving the labor
movement more and more in the center of this struggle.
There are new problems because of the systemic nature of crisis.
Our discussion should examine what adjustments can be made in
layoffs so that the biggest burden does not fall on racially and
nationally oppressed workers as it currently does. The main
principle is to make the company pay and fight for solutions that
preserve class unity. The fight for affirmative action must be
closely connected to other radical proposals, such as a shorter
work week with no cut in pay.
We should assert that the fight for affirmative action in the
labor movement is necessary to class unity, that it is a class
issue as well as a democratic issue.
Our discussion should also examine how to elevate the role of the
labor movement in the fight against police brutality, housing
discrimination, immigrant rights, and the dismantlement of public
education to mention a few issues. Here too we should discuss the
racist dimension of these issues, show how their roots lie in the
system of capitalism and its new stage of crisis, and come up
with concrete initiatives.
The fight for class unity must also take up unity between the
trade union movement and the unemployed giving special attention
to the racist pattern in layoffs. The Jobs and Equality Campaign
takes on special importance in relation to this issue.
We should examine as well the connection between the fight for
the full equality of African Americans, Mexican Americans,
American Indians, Asians, Arabs and other racially and nationally
oppressed peoples with the question of the rights of labor, as
both are restricted and suppressed by monopoly capital. And we
should do it keeping in mind the new level of class consciousness
among workers.
Finally, we should probe how to better connect the self and class
interests of white workers to the fight against racism and for
equality. How can we convince white workers that fighting racism
is necessary not simply because it is morally correct, but
because it hinders the cause of the whole working class, and
distorts and disfigures the whole society.
We should also find better arguments to demonstrate that the
fight against racism is in the self-interest of white workers,
showing that it holds down the wages of all workers and creates
obstacles to trade union and class unity. In this regard it
should be emphasized that white workers have a special
responsibility to step up the fight. This special responsibility
has to be linked to mutual self-interest of different sections of
the working class, that the emancipation of each section depends
on united struggle of against all forms of bigotry and
discrimination.
1993 elections - Racism had a serious impact on the recent
elections, serving to divert and confuse an electorate which is
angry, worried about jobs and insecure about the future. Playing
on this economic distress, and to deal with the fact that there
is growing sentiment that something is deeply wrong with the
system, the ruling class used racism to create the perception
that the problem is crime and violence, that the criminals are
Black and Brown people, especially youth.
This sharpened use of racism weakened the necessary coalitions
and key elected officials were defeated in several states and
cities. In New York City, a stepped up racist drive of
ultra-right forces grouped around the Guiliani candidacy pushed
the idea that Mayor Dinkins' administration was incompetent and
had not addressed crime. The charge of incompetence was deeply
racist in origin and inspiration. On the issue of crime it was
implied that Dinkins was weak because he is African American;
ignored was the fact that the crime rate actually went down
during his administration. The issue of crime and violence was
pushed to the fore in the election debate, with the facts falling
victim to hysteria and fear.
The November elections demonstrated how critical unity is in the
electoral arena; our role is to show that these defeats hurt the
working class as a whole, and not just Black and Brown people;
and that to make any legislative gains in terms of jobs, labor's
rights, against privatization, etc, we must increase the
representation of Black, Latino and labor elected officials at
all levels of government.
There were also positive trends in the elections, with growing
recognition that the key to victories of independent and
progressive campaigns is the alliance of labor, Mexican American,
African American, Puerto Rican and other racially and nationally
oppressed peoples.
Under capitalism there is constant anti-working- class
ideological pressure. The ruling class pushes ideas that weaken
unity, and deny, distort or erase working-class history. The main
weapons in its arsenal are racism and anti-Communism.
Our discussion should examine what are the trends and
developments in mass thought patterns around this question. How
has the heightened racist drive affected people's thinking
specifically and on what issues? How can masses be moved in a
positive direction in the fight against racism?
The multi-racial, multi-national working class and indeed the
country and the entire people face a dilemma: the essence of
which is that there is a desire to act but an inability to do so.
There is a crisis of inaction in the fight against racism. One
reason for this crisis of inaction is a continuing double
standard and blame-the-victim concept, which stem from an as yet
insufficient understanding of the systemic source of racism.
Mass Thought Patterns - Most whites accept the notion that racism
is morally wrong. And moral arguments can be powerful weapons in
the fight against it. >From this standpoint it is important to
take people where they are and build on these achievements. How
can we build on this desire to act?
As a result of the Civil Rights movement and the struggles for
equality, important progress has been made in countering the
worst influences of outright racism in people's thinking. A
majority of Americans support and believe in racial equality. A
majority of white people oppose racism as they understand it.
Among white workers there is substantial recognition of the
commonality of labor's rights and the struggle for equality of
all racially oppressed people. Together with Black, Latino, Asian
and Arab workers, this constitutes a powerful anti-racist
majority sentiment in the country.
This sentiment must be activized and turned into a powerful
stream of struggle in combatting the new growth of racism. It
must be the basis of launching new powerful blows at the system
of racist institutions and the monopoly capitalist economic
system which undergirds it. It must be tapped into in the
unfolding of the Campaign for Jobs and Equality and a new Civil
Rights Act.
The struggle to change mass thought patterns in an anti-racist
direction is an important aspect of the ideological forms of the
class struggle. It can help move the working class and other
strata in an anti-monopoly, anti-imperialist, pro-working class,
and pro-democratic direction. It can help deepen class
consciousness and assist in the emergence of socialist
consciousness.
While basing the fight against racism on the premise of majority
support for these goals recognition must be made of trends that
move in the opposite direction. The ultra-right has regrouped
after Bush's defeat and won significant victories in the past
elections. The Christian evangelical right, the Catholic church,
and the forces around Perot are conducting campaigns aimed at
increasing racism's influence, using the crime issue, and
targeting multi-culturalism in education and Rainbow curriculum.
As with all other problems and struggles, it is absolutely
essential that we have a class perspective on the struggle
against racism. In the broad movements, in which there are
anti-racist sentiments and activity, there are classless concepts
of racism which don't get at the root cause and the necessary
kinds of solutions. One expression is the idea that white workers
are more racist than other sections of the white population,
which ignores the history of and relationship between the fight
for equality and the labor movement, and denies the material
basis and necessity for working-class unity of Black, Brown and
white. And, it is in the labor movement where we see the greatest
progress and most significant developments in the struggle
against racism in the last period.
Mass Media - The most powerful form for the dissemination of
racism are the mass media and popular culture, both of which are
controlled by the ruling class, and which impact on how people
develop their understanding of and attitude towards people of
other nationalities and cultures. Racist portrayals of the
racially and nationally oppressed are at new levels, and there
has been an erosion in the gains made in this area during the
Civil Rights period. Modern-day minstrels have appeared on T.V.
and racist images of Mexicans, Puerto Ricans and Native American
Indians are frequently aired. There is an attempt to convince the
American people that racism in comedy is acceptable, as
demonstrated by the recent white actor appearing in black face.
People have to be helped to see that what is shown on television,
portrayed in movies, and played on the radio are related to the
system of racism, and not separate and apart from what's
happening in the economy and in society generally. Communists can
bring a class analysis to the public debate on whether what is
found in music and on television simply reflects reality or helps
to create it.
For example, there is a relationship between the struggle around
NAFTA, heightened anti-immigrant propaganda and the idea that
corporations should be allowed to move to wherever they can make
the greatest profit, as well as the fact that Congress recently
funded an extension in unemployment benefits by cutting
disability payments for immigrants.
The Party can help people see and understand these relationships,
and the systemic character of the problems. There is debate,
coming from many points on the political spectrum, as to whether
or not there are solutions. Can racism be eliminated, can
equality ever be achieved? Some have put forward the idea of the
permanence of racism and have expressed concern that nothing can
be done about it.
Our Party's ability to provide answers to this most basic
question is absolutely essential.
Marxism-Leninism is more, rather than less, necessary and useful
to provide basic answers. At a moment when masses are searching
for the way out of this economic crisis, we must find ways to
show that it is the system of capitalism that is in crisis, that
the problem lies with capitalism's putting "profit before
people." Likewise on the question of the cause of and solutions
to racism. Our analysis of racism's roots in exploitative class
relations of capitalist society is key, both to pointing to ways
to fight racism and for equality, and to build class unity so
that we can make the fundamental change that is necessary to
solve basic problems.
We are confident that there can be victories in the fight against
racism and for equality, because we see the basis for unity
against racism among all working people. The fight against racism
and for class unity is integrally related to the struggle for
socialism. These questions are linked to the very laws and nature
of capitalism.
The relationship between class and racial oppression under
capitalism is the key point around which working-class unity is
being built. Such unity is the foundation and the glue for the
kinds of broad movements which are leading the fight for economic
justice.
Just as we struggle today to defend and expand the economic and
democratic rights of the working class, while we point to the
capitalist system as the root of the problems, likewise we insist
on a special struggle for equality and against racism for only on
this basis can the entire class be united. At the same time we
show that only when the basis for division and antagonisms is
eliminated, can equality be fully realized.
The fight against racism is related to the struggle for socialism
not only because socialism is the ultimate solution to racism and
discrimination, but because socialism will only be won by a
strong, united, fighting working class, Black, Brown and white,
leading the whole people.
Influences on the Party - The struggle against the influences of
racism within the Party is an ongoing struggle, but at certain
moments requires even more attention and collective effort. The
increase in the promotion of racism by the ruling class in this
period means just that.
A correct approach to the struggle against racism must flow from
our class analysis. The main task is to elevate the level of
understanding and struggle against the racist ruling class
offensive.
How we approach the question of racism's impact on our Party is
very important. Struggle against influences of racism must unify
and strengthen and aim to improve the clubs' atmosphere, inner
life and activity. It must be in the context of activity, of
involvement in struggles of people, and in responding to events.
Influences of racism in the Party take different forms. Because
it is so directly part of the country's experience all whites are
to one extent or another influenced by it. The first step in the
fight against the influences of racism is to recognize it. It
cannot be fought against if it is not seen. Developing a capacity
for self-criticism is a most important weapon in this fight.
The main expression of the influence of racism in the Party is
reflected in weaknesses or failure to take responsibility and
initiative in the fight against racism.
Insensitivity on the part of white comrades reflects itself in
various forms: in the failure to accept leadership from African
American, Latino, and Native American Indian comrades - this is
particularly so with regard to minority women; in placing
standards for leadership on them that either exceed or fall below
that of whites; in failures to consult or follow the standards of
collective leadership where minority comrades are concerned; and
in failing to fight for Black, white, Brown unity and composition
in Party collectives. These problems weaken collectivity, and
feed individualism and go- it-alone attitudes.
Another expression of the influences of racism is insensitivity
to the dignity, intelligence, self-respect, and national culture
of racially and nationally oppressed comrades. Insensitivity most
often comes to the surface during tense situations, and can take
the form of curtness, impatience, talking in an angry tone, or
shouting. In its most gross form it is also reflected in making
racially disparaging statements about other peoples and cultures.
Expressions of outright insensitivity increase when there isn't
struggle, and when the level of racism in the society generally
have sharpened. Insensitivity reflects an underlying attitude of
white superiority. It is expressed in disrespectful or arrogant
treatment of racially oppressed comrades. Insensitivity is not
only a matter of personal behavior, but is a reflection of lack
of understanding of the crucial nature of racism in our society,
its damage to the cause of the whole working class, its pervasive
nature, and as well the fact that it can be beaten.
Any and all forms of chauvinistic behavior against racially and
nationally oppressed comrades is destructive of the essential
Black-Brown-white unity of our Party, and is unacceptable.
Paternalism - Paternalism is another expression of racism's
influences in the Party, and is one of the biggest problems
because it may not be as obvious. Paternalism reflects an
attitude of superiority, and a lack of understanding that
equality is necessary for the whole class to advance, that the
fight for equality is necessary to the fight for socialism, that
Party unity is essential. Paternalism is destructive because it
is phony. Paternalism damages collectivity and weakens one's
ability to effectively struggle.
Paternalism corrupts both the white comrades who express it and
the comrades at the receiving end, it is an opportunist approach
to fighting racism, and inhibits political growth, ideological
development and real unity.
Paternalism is exhibited in situations in which racially and
nationally oppressed comrades are treated with condescension. It
can take the form of ingratiating oneself to minority comrades;
expressing the belief that racially oppressed comrades are beyond
criticism; in having good relations with minority comrades when
they agree with you, but condemning them when they do not.
Paternalism is reflected in excessive praise, hanging on every
word, and "missionary-like" tendencies to work only among the
racially and nationally oppressed.
In our discussion, we should concretely examine expressions of
the influences of racism, to deepen white comrades' understanding
of the objective basis for the fight against racism and for
unity. The concept that it is a special responsibility of white
Communists to take initiative in the fight against racism and to
build anti-racist sentiment among white people, is an important
one.
Both paternalism and insensitivity most often reflect attitudes
of white superiority that comrades may not be conscious of. The
struggle must be on the basis of confidence that these weaknesses
can be recognized and overcome, in an atmosphere which is at once
conducive to raising such criticisms as well as helping comrades
to grow.
The fight against all forms of the influences of racism is
important in yet another respect: people join the Communist Party
because they expect a higher level of understanding and conduct.
They expect higher ideological and moral standards than what they
see in society generally. And so it should be. In this regard
manifestations of influences of racism are particularly harmful
and must be consistently dealt with.
In the leadership of the Party, the struggle for the highest
working-class standards on this question is even more important.
Every leading Communist should consider as their own the fight
for the most comradely, respectful, equal relations among Black,
Brown and white in the collectives of the Party.
The atmosphere in this discussion should be comradely and
objective, and help comrades to grow in their understanding of
racism and our Party's role. The discussion should contribute to
an atmosphere in the Party in which people of all racial and
national backgrounds are comfortable and work as equals.
Party's Traditions and Role - The Party is unique in that it
bases its fight against racism on its working-class
Marxist-Leninist science. Our Communist plus and understanding of
the class source of the struggle against racism and for equality
enables us to play a unique role in the fight against racism in
all of its many forms and for multi-racial, multi- national
unity. This fight requires constant vigilance and the maintenance
of high working- class standards. Consistent application of this
principle and deep involvement in struggle will enable the Party
to make yet another historic contribution in the fight against
racism today.
The Communist Party has always been identified and identified
itself with the fight for equality and against racism. A
principled and consistent approach to this fight is a fundamental
premise of Communist politics and ideology. In a sense, it is
part of our Party's birthright, one of the main reasons for its
founding by Socialist Party members who rejected its opportunist
and ultimately chauvinistic approach to the fight against racism
and for equality, and declared that this fight was essential to
the class struggle and the working class' fight against
capitalism.
From the fight to organize the industrial unions, the defense of
the victims of legal lynchings such as in the Scottsboro case,
the organizing of sharecroppers in the South, to the Civil Rights
movement, our Party has a long and proud history. Communists have
helped organize and mobilize masses in the fight against racism,
and raise the level of understanding of racism's roots in the
capitalist system and its role in dividing the working class and
hobbling struggle.
Perhaps most important is our Communist conviction that unity is
necessary, and our confidence that it is possible.
As part of the discussion we should look at how to elevate the
fight against racism in the movements in which we are active, how
to build the Jobs and Equality campaign, but as well, what
specific campaigns against racism the Party and YCL could help
initiate.
For example, on the question of the use of racist symbols by
professional sports teams: the Party could help spark a movement,
for which there would be mass support, and which could make a big
contribution to the public debate about racism and the fight for
equality. We should initiate a new campaign to outlaw racism:
racist acts, statements, and attempts to undermine or not enforce
existing laws. A central thrust of the Jobs and Equality campaign
and the call for a new Civil Rights act must be to reassert the
call for outlawing racism.
This Party-wide discussion will make an important contribution to
a collective updating and refreshing of our approach, and to a
greater level of activity and involvement in the struggle against
racism, and for equality and unity of our multi- racial,
multi-national working class.
##30##
Political Affairs Monthly Theoretical Journal of the Communist Party, USA |